Justice John M. Harlan's Lone Dissents

Edwards v. Kearzey

No. 566
96 U.S. 595

Decided Monday, April 15, 1878
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

96 U.S. 595

Brine v. Insurance Co.

No. 279
96 U.S. 627

Decided Monday, May 13, 1878
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

96 U.S. 627

County of Cass v. Gillett

No. 68
100 U.S. 585

Decided Monday, December 8, 1879
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

100 U.S. 585

Spring Co. v. Knowlton

No. 200
103 U.S. 49

Decided Monday, January 31, 1881
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

103 U.S. 49

Jarrolt v. Moberly

No. 173
103 U.S. 580

Decided Monday, April 11, 1881
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

103 U.S. 580

Bailey v. Railroad Co.

No. 27
106 U.S. 109

Decided Monday, November 6, 1882
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

106 U.S. 109

Transportation Co. v. Parkersburg

No. 172
107 U.S. 691

Decided Monday, April 30, 1883
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

107 U.S. 691

Illinois Central R. Co. v. Illinois

No. 241
108 U.S. 541

Decided Monday, May 7, 1883
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

108 U.S. 541

Civil Rights Cases

No. 1
109 U.S. 3

Decided Monday, October 15, 1883
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

109 U.S. 3

Louisiana ex rel. Folsom v. Mayor and Administrators of New Orleans

No. 34
109 U.S. 285

Decided Monday, November 19, 1883
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

109 U.S. 285

Canada Southern R. Co. v. Gebhard

No. 72
109 U.S. 527

Decided Monday, December 10, 1883
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

109 U.S. 527

Hurtado v. California

No. 1207
110 U.S. 516

Decided Monday, March 3, 1884
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

110 U.S. 516

Litchfield v. Ballou

114 U.S. 190

Decided Monday, April 6, 1885
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

114 U.S. 190

Tennessee Bond Cases

No. 163
114 U.S. 663

Decided Monday, May 4, 1885
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

114 U.S. 663

Thompson v. Allen County

No. 60
115 U.S. 550

Decided Monday, November 23, 1885
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

115 U.S. 550

Philadelphia Fire Assn. v. New York

No. 15
119 U.S. 110

Decided Monday, November 15, 1886
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

119 U.S. 110

In re Ayers

123 U.S. 443

Decided Monday, December 5, 1887
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

123 U.S. 443

Marshall v. United States

No. 57
131 U.S. 391

Decided Monday, November 19, 1888
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

131 U.S. 391

Denny v. Bennett

No. 67
128 U.S. 489

Decided Monday, November 26, 1888
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

128 U.S. 489

Baldwin v. Kansas

No. 1154
129 U.S. 52

Decided Monday, January 14, 1889
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

129 U.S. 52

Freeland v. Williams

No. 267
131 U.S. 405

Decided Monday, May 13, 1889
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

131 U.S. 405

North Carolina v. Temple

No. 392
134 U.S. 22

Decided Monday, March 3, 1890
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

134 U.S. 22

Louisiana ex rel. New York Guaranty & Indemnity Co. v. Steele

No. 140
134 U.S. 230

Decided Monday, March 10, 1890
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

134 U.S. 230

Shelton v. Platt

No. 1155
139 U.S. 591

Decided Monday, April 6, 1891
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

139 U.S. 591

Henderson Bridge Co. v. Henderson City

No. 1007
141 U.S. 679

Decided Monday, December 7, 1891
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

141 U.S. 679

Kaukauna Water Power Co. v. Green Bay & Mississippi Canal Co.

No. 65
142 U.S. 254

Decided Monday, December 21, 1891
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

142 U.S. 254

Horn Silver Mining Co. v. New York

No. 48
143 U.S. 305

Decided Monday, February 29, 1892
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

143 U.S. 305

Nesbit v. Riverside Independent Dist.

No. 212
144 U.S. 610

Decided Monday, April 18, 1892
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

144 U.S. 610

Ficklen v. Shelby County Taxing Dist.

No. 97
145 U.S. 1

Decided Monday, April 11, 1892
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

145 U.S. 1

Shaw v. Quincy Mining Co.

No. 13 Orig.
145 U.S. 444

Decided Monday, May 16, 1892
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

145 U.S. 444

Hedges v. Dixon County

No. 62
150 U.S. 182

Decided Monday, November 13, 1893
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

150 U.S. 182

Angle v. Chicago, St. P., M. & O. R. Co.

No. 73
151 U.S. 1

Decided Wednesday, January 3, 1894
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

151 U.S. 1

Martin's Administrator v. Baltimore & Ohio R. Co.

No. 67
151 U.S. 673

Decided Monday, February 5, 1894
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

151 U.S. 673

Seeberger v. Schweyer

No. 295
153 U.S. 609

Decided Monday, May 14, 1894
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

153 U.S. 609

Lloyd v. Matthews

No. 81
155 U.S. 222

Decided Monday, December 3, 1894
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

155 U.S. 222

United States v. E. C. Knight Co.

No. 675
156 U.S. 1

Decided Monday, January 21, 1895
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

156 U.S. 1

Todd v. United States

No. 822
158 U.S. 278

Decided Monday, May 20, 1895
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

158 U.S. 278

New York, L. E. & W. R. Co. v. Pennsylvania

No. 263
158 U.S. 431

Decided Monday, May 27, 1895
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

158 U.S. 431

Tioga Railroad Company v. Pennsylvania

No. 264
158 U.S. 440

Decided Monday, May 27, 1895
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

158 U.S. 440

Wisconsin Central R. Co. v. Forsythe

No. 238
159 U.S. 46

Decided Monday, June 3, 1895
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

159 U.S. 46

St. Louis & San Francisco R. Co. v. James

No. 242
161 U.S. 545

Decided Monday, March 2, 1896
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

161 U.S. 545

Talton v. Mayes

No. 227
163 U.S. 376

Decided Monday, May 18, 1896
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

163 U.S. 376

United States v. Perkins

No. 422
163 U.S. 625

Decided Monday, May 25, 1896
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

163 U.S. 625

United States v. Fitch

No. 828
163 U.S. 631

Decided Monday, May 25, 1896
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

163 U.S. 631

Wiborg v. United States

No. 986
163 U.S. 632

Decided Monday, May 25, 1896
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

163 U.S. 632

Plessy v. Ferguson

No. 210
163 U.S. 537

Decided Monday, May 18, 1896
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

163 U.S. 537

Noble v. Mitchell

No. 101
164 U.S. 367

Decided Monday, November 30, 1896
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

164 U.S. 367

France v. United States

No. 495
164 U.S. 676

Decided Monday, January 4, 1897
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

164 U.S. 676

Robertson v. Baldwin

No. 334
165 U.S. 275

Decided Monday, January 25, 1897
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

165 U.S. 275

Graves v. United States

No. 31
165 U.S. 323

Decided Monday, February 15, 1897
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

165 U.S. 323

Oakes v. Mase

No. 182
165 U.S. 363

Decided Monday, February 15, 1897
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

165 U.S. 363

The Three Friends

No. 701
166 U.S. 1

Decided Monday, March 1, 1897
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

166 U.S. 1

Martin v. Atchison, T. & S. F. R. Co.

No. 170
166 U.S. 399

Decided Monday, April 5, 1897
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

166 U.S. 399

Walker v. Collins

No. 59
167 U.S. 57

Decided Monday, May 10, 1897
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

167 U.S. 57

United States v. American Bell Telephone Co.

No. 344
167 U.S. 224

Decided Monday, May 10, 1897
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

167 U.S. 224

California Bank v. Kennedy

No. 206
167 U.S. 362

Decided Monday, May 24, 1897
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

167 U.S. 362

ICC v. Cincinnati, N. O. & T. P. R. Co.

No. 733
167 U.S. 479

Decided Monday, May 24, 1897
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

167 U.S. 479

Savannah, Florida and Western Railway Company v. Florida Fruit Exchange

No. 141
167 U.S. 512

Decided Monday, May 24, 1897
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

167 U.S. 512

ICC v. Alabama Midland R. Co.

No. 203
168 U.S. 144

Decided Monday, November 8, 1897
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

168 U.S. 144

Beley v. Naphtaly

No. 180
169 U.S. 353

Decided Monday, February 28, 1898
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

169 U.S. 353

Smith v. Naphtaly

No. 181
169 U.S. 365

Decided Monday, February 28, 1898
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

169 U.S. 365

Backus v. Fort Street Union Depot Co.

No. 55
169 U.S. 557

Decided Monday, March 7, 1898
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

169 U.S. 557

Northern Pacific R. Co. v. Smith

No. 93
171 U.S. 260

Decided Tuesday, May 31, 1898
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

171 U.S. 260

Hopkins v. United States

No. 210
171 U.S. 578

Decided Monday, October 24, 1898
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

171 U.S. 578

Anderson v. United States

No. 181
171 U.S. 604

Decided Monday, October 24, 1898
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

171 U.S. 604

Guthrie Nat. Bank v. Guthrie

No. 133
173 U.S. 528

Decided Monday, April 3, 1899
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

173 U.S. 528

Louisville v. Bank of Louisville

No. 358
174 U.S. 439

Decided Monday, May 15, 1899
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

174 U.S. 439

Missouri, K. & T. R. Co. v. McCann

No. 11
174 U.S. 580

Decided Monday, May 22, 1899
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

174 U.S. 580

New England R. Co. v. Conroy

No. 42
175 U.S. 323

Decided Monday, December 4, 1899
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

175 U.S. 323

Bolln v. Nebraska

No. 393
176 U.S. 83

Decided Monday, January 15, 1900
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

176 U.S. 83

Baltimore & Ohio Southwestern R. Co. v. Voigt

No. 88
176 U.S. 498

Decided Monday, February 26, 1900
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

176 U.S. 498

Maxwell v. Dow

No. 384
176 U.S. 581

Decided Monday, February 26, 1900
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

176 U.S. 581

Waters-Pierce Oil Co. v. Texas

No. 97
177 U.S. 28

Decided Monday, March 19, 1900
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

177 U.S. 28

Camden & Suburban R. Co. v. Stetson

No. 174
177 U.S. 172

Decided Monday, April 9, 1900
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

177 U.S. 172

Williams v. Fears

No. 287
179 U.S. 270

Decided Monday, December 10, 1900
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

179 U.S. 270

Chesapeake & Ohio R. Co. v. Kentucky

No. 103
179 U.S. 388

Decided Monday, December 3, 1900
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

179 U.S. 388

Clews v. Jamieson

No. 245
182 U.S. 461

Decided Monday, May 27, 1901
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

182 U.S. 461

ICC v. Clyde S. S. Co.

No. 68
181 U.S. 29

Decided Monday, April 8, 1901
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

181 U.S. 29

Louisville Trust Co. v. Comingor

No. 309
184 U.S. 18

Decided Monday, January 27, 1902
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

184 U.S. 18

Nutting v. Massachusetts

No. 32
183 U.S. 553

Decided Monday, January 13, 1902
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

183 U.S. 553

Francis v. United States

No. 80
188 U.S. 375

Decided Monday, February 23, 1903
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

188 U.S. 375

Rankin v. Fidelity Ins., Trust & Safe Deposit Co.

No. 178
189 U.S. 242

Decided Monday, April 6, 1903
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

189 U.S. 242

Chattanooga Nat. Building and Loan Assn. v. Denson

No. 206
189 U.S. 408

Decided Monday, April 27, 1903
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

189 U.S. 408

ICC v. Louisville & Nashville R. Co.

No. 214
190 U.S. 273

Decided Monday, May 18, 1903
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

190 U.S. 273

Lone Wolf v. Hitchcock

No. 275
187 U.S. 553

Decided Monday, January 5, 1903
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

187 U.S. 553

Schick v. United States

No. 222
195 U.S. 65

Decided Tuesday, May 31, 1904
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

195 U.S. 65

Dorr v. United States

No. 583
195 U.S. 138

Decided Tuesday, May 31, 1904
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

195 U.S. 138

West v. Louisiana

No. 230
194 U.S. 258

Decided Monday, May 2, 1904
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

194 U.S. 258

Giles v. Teasley

No. 337
193 U.S. 146

Decided Tuesday, February 23, 1904
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

193 U.S. 146

Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Pennsylvania R. Co.

No. 199
195 U.S. 540

Decided Monday, December 12, 1904
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

195 U.S. 540

Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Pennsylvania R. Co.

No. 90
195 U.S. 594

Decided Monday, December 12, 1904
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

195 U.S. 594

Louisville & Nashville R. Co. v. West Coast Naval Stores Co.

No. 225
198 U.S. 483

Decided Monday, May 29, 1905
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

198 U.S. 483

In re Heff

No. 14
197 U.S. 488

Decided Monday, April 10, 1905
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

197 U.S. 488

Knapp v. Lake Shore & Michigan Southern R. Co.

No. 251
197 U.S. 536

Decided Monday, April 10, 1905
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

197 U.S. 536

Dallemagne v. Moisan

No. 104
197 U.S. 169

Decided Monday, March 13, 1905
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

197 U.S. 169

Northern Pacific R. Co. v. Ely

No. 102
197 U.S. 1

Decided Monday, February 20, 1905
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

197 U.S. 1

Northern Pacific R. Co. v. Hasse

No. 118
197 U.S. 9

Decided Monday, February 20, 1905
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

197 U.S. 9

American Express Co. v. Iowa

No. 67
196 U.S. 133

Decided Tuesday, January 3, 1905
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

196 U.S. 133

Adams Express Co. v. Iowa

No. 82
196 U.S. 147

Decided Tuesday, January 3, 1905
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

196 U.S. 147

Burton v. United States

No. 343
196 U.S. 283

Decided Monday, January 16, 1905
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

196 U.S. 283

Vicksburg v. Vicksburg Waterworks Co.

No. 133
202 U.S. 453

Decided Monday, May 21, 1906
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

202 U.S. 453

Adams Express Co. v. Kentucky

No. 331
206 U.S. 129

Decided Monday, May 13, 1907
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

206 U.S. 129

Adams Express Co. v. Kentucky

No. 332
206 U.S. 138

Decided Monday, May 13, 1907
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

206 U.S. 138

American Express Co. of N. Y. v. Kentucky

No. 583
206 U.S. 139

Decided Monday, May 13, 1907
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

206 U.S. 139

Patterson v. Colorado ex rel. Attorney General of Colo.

No. 223
205 U.S. 454

Decided Monday, April 15, 1907
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

205 U.S. 454

Moore v. McGuire

No. 222
205 U.S. 214

Decided Monday, March 25, 1907
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

205 U.S. 214

Tinsley v. Treat

No. 369
205 U.S. 20

Decided Monday, March 4, 1907
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

205 U.S. 20

Kessler v. Treat

No. 370
205 U.S. 33

Decided Monday, March 4, 1907
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

205 U.S. 33

Serra v. Mortiga

No. 202
204 U.S. 470

Decided Monday, February 25, 1907
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

204 U.S. 470

Tilt v. Kelsey

No. 18
207 U.S. 43

Decided Monday, October 21, 1907
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

207 U.S. 43

Paraiso v. United States

No. 23
207 U.S. 368

Decided Monday, December 16, 1907
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

207 U.S. 368

Flemister v. United States

No. 70
207 U.S. 372

Decided Monday, December 16, 1907
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

207 U.S. 372

Ughbanks v. Armstrong

No. 435
208 U.S. 481

Decided Monday, February 24, 1908
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

208 U.S. 481

Continental Paper Bag Co. v. Eastern Paper Bag Co.

No. 202
210 U.S. 405

Decided Monday, June 1, 1908
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

210 U.S. 405

United States v. Chandler-Dunbar Water Power Co.

No. 599
209 U.S. 447

Decided Monday, April 20, 1908
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

209 U.S. 447

Ex parte Young

No. 10 Orig.
209 U.S. 123

Decided Monday, March 23, 1908
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

209 U.S. 123

Hunter v. Wood

No. 474
209 U.S. 205

Decided Monday, March 23, 1908
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

209 U.S. 205

Twining v. New Jersey

No. 10
211 U.S. 78

Decided Monday, November 9, 1908
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

211 U.S. 78

Green County v. Quinlan

No. 351
211 U.S. 582

Decided Monday, January 4, 1909
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

211 U.S. 582

Green County v. Thomas' Executor

No. 352
211 U.S. 598

Decided Monday, January 4, 1909
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

211 U.S. 598

In re Dunn

No. 10 Orig.
212 U.S. 374

Decided Tuesday, February 23, 1909
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

212 U.S. 374

United States ex rel. Attorney General v. Delaware & Hudson Co.

No. 559
213 U.S. 366

Decided Monday, May 3, 1909
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

213 U.S. 366

Adams Express Co. v. Kentucky

No. 144
214 U.S. 218

Decided Monday, May 24, 1909
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

214 U.S. 218

Macon Grocery Co. v. Atlantic Coast Line R. Co.

No. 351
215 U.S. 501

Decided Monday, January 17, 1910
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

215 U.S. 501

Pendleton v. United States

No. 53
216 U.S. 305

Decided Monday, February 21, 1910
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

216 U.S. 305

Chiles v. Chesapeake & Ohio R. Co.

No. 158
218 U.S. 71

Decided Tuesday, May 31, 1910
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

218 U.S. 71

Hendrix v. United States

No. 319
219 U.S. 79

Decided Tuesday, January 3, 1911
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

219 U.S. 79

Gavieres v. United States

No. 102
220 U.S. 338

Decided Monday, April 3, 1911
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

220 U.S. 338

Dowdell v. United States

No. 131
221 U.S. 325

Decided Monday, May 15, 1911
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

221 U.S. 325

Montello Salt Co. v. Utah

No. 136
221 U.S. 452

Decided Monday, May 29, 1911
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

221 U.S. 452

Hopkins v. Clemson

No. 70
221 U.S. 636

Decided Monday, May 29, 1911
Dissent by Justice John M. Harlan

221 U.S. 636